This movie is a favorite of mine and many others too. I created a Hocus Pocus mantel last year which I LOVED.
However, this year I'm loving my apple orchard themed mantel and didn't want to take it down. So instead, I set up my Hocus Pocus decor on our dining room cafe shelves. This way I get the best of both and I'm actually loving how it turned out!
I tried to include all the pieces of the movie that I could. I have the black flame candle, all 7 ingredients in the witch's potion, I created the friendly zombie Billy's headstone, and found a cute black cat to represent Binks. Then I found a fun print that sort of fit the vintage look and framed it, along with a picture of my kids in my favorite Halloween costumes of theirs - Jack and Sally.
I added some candles and some black meshy fabric and it all came together nicely!
Here's a video of the whole display and up close details.